topic RGB To HLS 8u P3-C3 conversions in Intel® Integrated Performance Primitives

RGB To HLS 8u P3-C3 conversions

b_k_ — Mon, 09 May 2016 09:50:03 GMT

Hello,

I was trying to replace ippiRGBToHLS_8u_C3R with ippiBGRToHLS_8u_C3P3R.

The functions give differing results for some RGB values, and ippiBGRToHLS_8u_C3P3R gives differing results for the same RGB values.

Here is an example:

// a BGR image, 5 pixels per row (R,G,B)
// padding to 16 bytes
IppStatus st;
Ipp8u BGR[16] = {  91, 182, 204,  91, 182, 204,  91, 182, 204,  91, 182, 204,  91, 182, 204, 0 };
Ipp8u RGB[16] = { 204, 182,  91, 204, 182,  91, 204, 182,  91, 204, 182,  91, 204, 182,  91, 0 };
IppiSize roi = { 5, 1 };

// convert RGB->HLS
Ipp8u HLS3ch[16];
st = ippiRGBToHLS_8u_C3R(RGB, 16, HLS3ch, 16, roi);
// extract to channels
Ipp8u H0[8 ], L0[8 ], S0[8 ];
Ipp8u* pHLS0[] = { H0, L0, S0 };
st = ippiCopy_8u_C3P3R(HLS3ch, 16, pHLS0, 8, roi);

Ipp8u H[8 ], L[8 ], S[8 ];
Ipp8u* pHLS[] = { H, L, S };
st = ippiBGRToHLS_8u_C3P3R(BGR, 16, pHLS, 8, roi);

The H0 and H channels are identical, as are the L0 and L channels. But

S0 = 134 134 134 134 134

S = 133 133 133 133 134

Using: i7-4790, IPP8.1 32bit, Win10 64bit.

Hi,

Chao_Y_Intel — Tue, 10 May 2016 01:50:33 GMT

Hi,

Thanks for your report. does that only have the difference with "1"? We will have further check on this.

Thanks,
Chao

Hi,

b_k_ — Tue, 10 May 2016 07:20:00 GMT

Hi,

I checked on some other images and the differences were 1's only.

Attached is an image where many differences occure in the H,L,S channels.

By the way, using the values from the example {91, 182, 204} in an image that is 1x1 size results in identical HLS values

Hi,

b_k_ — Tue, 10 May 2016 10:56:06 GMT

Hi,

The results of ippiBGRToHLS_8u_P3R also differ from the results of ippiBGRToHLS_8u_C3R.