NUC8I5BEH random system halt, with flicker of screen occasionally
I bought NUC8I5BEH recently, it is not working well…. Below is the hardware:
ADATA ram 8GB*2
Intel 535 240GB SSD
ADATA ram 8GB*2
Samsung EVO 970 500GB SSD
OS: Win 10 1803
Drivers, latest using intel driver assistant. Windows updated to latest version.
Random: 1-12 hours interval, never exceed 24 hours system halt
System halt: Screen suddenly stop moving. Mouse no response. Keyboard no response.
When system halt happen?
- while in normal using
- normal browsing
- editing document
- Playing youtube video etc….
What I have tested:
-Ram, tested normal with MemTest86
-SSD, installing Win 10 on Intel 535 240GB SSD problem repeats. Installing Win 10 on Samsung Evo 970 SSD. Problem repeats.
So, I then get a new NUC8I5BEH from the store to test whether the problem persist. Yes, the system halt repeats.
So, whether the NUC8I5BEH is a defective hardware? Or it is the driver issue? Please help….
Is it the same issue 2 year ago? https://forums.intel.com/s/question/0D50P0000490JAASA2/nuc7i5bnh-keeps-freezingcrashing-in-windows-1...
Thanks for helping. But I have decided to return the NUC. Below is some comments and notes.
The Ram I am using is ADATA Premier DDR-4 2400MHz 8GB (1x8GB) SODIMM AD4S240038G17-R. R may stands for retail version, it may be the same as AD4S240038G17-B. Since I have tested with the memtest86 program. I think the ram could be no error as seen in the screen shot. I am not going to do further testing, I have a lot of other work to do...
I have read the Amazon reviews, a significant proportion of users are not satisfied:
You may pay attention to the 1 star reviews, the product is not having a consistent good record...
Please work hard and get problems fixed. When the NUC has a good consistence of good quality and stability, I may purchase again in the future, but no this moment. Sorry.
Attached is the report, hope it may provide some information to help your company to find out the problem.
Thanks a lot again.
Adding some information here...
I bought another mainboard, using the same hardware, the PC is running continuously for 3 days without any issue. I am not going to buy Intel Nuc for at least 10 years and tell all my friends not to. From the amazon reviews, I think the product is not of consistence of good quality. And there has been no improvement, at least for the last 3 years. Very bad management and treat customers as fools and waste my precious time.
Here's how I resolved my flickering screen issue:
PC Set up: NUC8i3BEH with 2 Asus VE247H monitors, one connected to HDMI port, the second connected to thunderbolt via thunderbolt to HDMI cable.
Issue experienced: Upon start up, the screen connected to HDMI would flicker, and other screen connected to Thunderbolt would lose connectivity. When this occurred, the HDMI screen would flicker on and off every second. Occasionally I would get both screens to start and stay on, but eventually the thunderbolt screen would lose the HDMI signal.
After days of research and trying different things, I found that Windows default power management settings for USB devices is forcing the USB port to power down, even though I had the monitor on and connected to the NUC.
Solution that worked for me:
Opened DEVICE MANAGER
Opened Universal Serial Bus Controllers
Looked at the 'Properties' for each device within the USB controllers
Looked to see which have a tab within the profiles entitled 'Power Management' and unchecked the box 'allow the computer to turn off this device to save power'.
In my set up, the two that had a power management tab are 'Intel(R) USB 3.1 eXtensible Host Controller - 1.10(Microsoft)' & 'USB Root Hub (USB3.0)'. I probably only needed to change the 3.1 controller, but I did them both because I tried so many remedies before this that I was tired of retesting and failing.
Keep in mind that if this fix works for you that future window updates may default the settings back to power saving, so you may have to repeat these steps if your screen starts to flicker again.