Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Germano_C_
Beginner
65 Views

QuadMesh normal issue on a single workstation

Hi,

We are currently using Embree 2.9.0. - a single static scene with one or more TriangleMesh _or_ QuadMesh.

Everything is running and working fine _almost_ everywhere. We tested the software on Intel and non-intel CPUs, Opteron racks, VMs, 6 years old laptopts, whatever, and _everything_ is working great.

Except, that is, for a single PC with a core i7 2700k, There (and only there) QuadMeshes have an inverted normal on one of its 2 tris. And we simply cannot figure out why. Its a Windows 10 machine 64bit with 8 GB RAM and a 2700k. nothing special. still, QuadMeshes simply refuse to have the same normal direction on both triangles. I just would like to stress that this behaviour can only be seen on that particular machine only. Wherever else, the software handles QuadMeshes pretty good.

Now, I understand that without having a piece of source code it may be quite difficult to have an idea, I was just wondering if you ever experienced anything like that, or if it was a rare but known issue.

We tried setting RTC_SCENE_ROBUST, but aside from that, there are not much more flags we can play with. Anyway we simply dropped QuadMeshes and use TriangleMeshes everywhere (which I believe Embree internally does anyway), and everthing is fine.

Just FYI

thanks

PS: should you need pieces of source just contact me

0 Kudos
3 Replies
BenthinC_Intel
Employee
65 Views

Hi,

the inverted normal sounds strange and could be a buggy code path. Could you give us some more information:

- Does the inverted normal happen for the Embree tutorials too or only inside your app?

- Is this for the single ray interface only or do you trace packets/streams of rays?

- Could you pass 'verbose=2' to the embree configuration string to enable a more verbose output and send us the output?

If this does not provide further inside we might need a small reproducer (either binary or source code).

Thanks,

Carsten

Germano_C_
Beginner
65 Views

I will make some test and post the results

thanks for your quick answer

SvenW_Intel
Moderator
65 Views

Hi Germano, we located the issue and will fix it for the next release. Thus there is no need for you to provide additional information.

Reply