- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content

Greetings everyone!

I have a question concerning the (right) eigenvectors returned from (MKL) LAPACK's dgeev.

There is the dgeev example at

where the matrix

A = {{-1.01, 3.98, 3.30, 4.43, 7.31},

{ 0.86, 0.53, 8.26, 4.96, -6.43},

{-4.60, -7.04, -3.89, -7.66, -6.16},

{ 3.31, 5.29, 8.20, -7.33, 2.47},

{-4.81, 3.55, -1.51, 6.18, 5.58}};

is diagonalized. On my machine I can reproduce the results given in the link. Then, with more digits than provided in the example, the first eigenvalue and -vector (lambda, v) read (in Mathematica notation, "I" is the imaginary unit)

lambda = 2.858133 + 10.762750 I;

v = {0.108065 + 0.168648 I,

0.406313 - 0.259010 I,

0.102358 - 0.508802 I,

0.398631 - 0.091333 I,

0.539535 + 0.000000 I};

When I check in Mathematica if the eigenpair satisfies

A v = lambda v

(as it should, according to the documentation) it turns out that this is not the case :

in: A.v

out: { 4.441 + 11.539 I,

-5.131 + 13.895 I,

-5.630 - 19.365 I,

-3.115 + 6.718 I,

5.526 + 7.408 I };

in: lambda v

out: { -1.506 + 1.645 I,

-10.341 + 4.443 I,

-11.924 - 1.516 I,

-9.884 + 6.165 I,

1.542 + 5.806 I }

And indeed, the eigenvectors provided from Mathematica are different and they furthermore satisfy the eigenvalue equation as expected

in: {eval, evec} = Eigensystem;

in: A . evec[[1]]

out: { 3.225 - 0.344 I,

1.766 + 6.653 I,

-6.313 + 1.264 I,

0.933 + 3.021 I,

3.537 - 1.457 I}

in: eval[[1]] evec[[1]]

out: {3.225 - 0.344 I,

1.766 + 6.653 I,

-6.313 + 1.264 I,

0.933 + 3.021 I,

3.537 - 1.457 I}

Any idea where I am going wrong would be highly appreciated.

Have a nice day and thank you!

phys

Link Copied

- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content

Different packages choose different scaling for eigenvectors. Before comparing results, you should match the scaling.

The matrix you gave Mathematica is the transpose of the one in the MKL example. As a result, Mathematica gave you the left eigenvectors, whereas MKL gave you the right eigenvectors. If the matrix is not hermitian, the right and left eigenvectors differ.

- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content

- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic for Current User
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page