Inconsistency in the SDK (imageposition)

[AndreCarlucci]

I just would like to report  a small inconsistency in the SDK (is there a better place to report these things?

When getting a Joint positionImage, it is returned a PXCMPoint3DF32. (JointData)

When getting a hand positionImage, it is returned a PXCMPointF32 (QueryMassCenterImage)

I believe both should be PXCMPointF32 since Z is not present in image coordinates, right?

Thanks,

André

[Pubudu-Silva_Intel]

Andre,

Are you suggesting that both should not be  PXCMPointF32 ?

quote=Andre Carlucci]

I just would like to report  a small inconsistency in the SDK (is there a better place to report these things?

When getting a Joint positionImage, it is returned a PXCMPoint3DF32. (JointData)

When getting a hand positionImage, it is returned a PXCMPointF32 (QueryMassCenterImage)

I believe both should be PXCMPointF32 since Z is not present in image coordinates, right?

Thanks,

André

[AndreCarlucci]

Yes, they represent the same concept (position in the generated image) and they have no Z in this case.

[Dagan_E_Intel]

Thanks Andre,

Good catch!

The 3D dimension holds the depth at the X,Y location, which was thought to be helpful, but indeed both image positions should better have the same type for consistency and clearer usage

cheers,

Dagan