Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Highlighted
New Contributor II
99 Views

Algorithm problem - Fortran

Jump to solution

I have a Rainfall Runoff program that is based on the old Field Williams model, the original was developed in the 1970s. 

I think about this program a lot mainly because it is interesting Fortan code and both Field and Williams lectured me. 

My daughter - year 7 - US School in Texas had the following problem  - shown attached.  

She got the correct answer according to the grading, but I was interested and ran the problem in my mind through the FWM algorithm for runoff and detention.  After you have done hundreds of them by hand in teaching classes it is second nature.  

The picture does not show enough information to arrive at any of the conclusion, it would not be hard to run a sample into the FWM , but I think that is a waste. 

Or am I missing something in the algorithm. 

 

0 Kudos

Accepted Solutions
Highlighted
67 Views

>>The picture does not show enough information to arrive at any of the conclusion, it would not be hard to run a sample into the FWM , but I think that is a waste. 

Right, like:

1) How much water was poured into/onto the sample box
2) Prior to adding the water, what was the saturation level of the soil
3) What was the dispersion (e.g. sprinkled evenly or dumped from a beaker)
4) what was rate at which the water was applied
5) what was the temperature
6) soil composition
...

This said, the test she took was more or less a test of abstraction of the "Rainfall Runoff" problem, and I think, sufficient for a problem statement with a list of questions. Congratulate your daughter for getting it right.

Jim Dempsey

View solution in original post

2 Replies
Highlighted
68 Views

>>The picture does not show enough information to arrive at any of the conclusion, it would not be hard to run a sample into the FWM , but I think that is a waste. 

Right, like:

1) How much water was poured into/onto the sample box
2) Prior to adding the water, what was the saturation level of the soil
3) What was the dispersion (e.g. sprinkled evenly or dumped from a beaker)
4) what was rate at which the water was applied
5) what was the temperature
6) soil composition
...

This said, the test she took was more or less a test of abstraction of the "Rainfall Runoff" problem, and I think, sufficient for a problem statement with a list of questions. Congratulate your daughter for getting it right.

Jim Dempsey

View solution in original post

Highlighted
New Contributor II
58 Views

Jim:

Thanks, as usual you point out the obvious.  I will let her know.  

JMN

0 Kudos