Re: Stuck on the error: Verilog HDL Defparam Statement error at <location>: value for parameter "<name>" must be constant expression

AKhan88 · ‎02-24-2020

Hi,

I'm trying to support the synthesis of my system on both Vivado and Quartus. So far i've had tough luck with Quartus (probably due to my inexperience).

I have a package in which i have some functions which set up my local parameters in other RTL files. The functions look like:

function automatic int get_settings_loading_serialised_width( );
 
      int settings_loading_serialised_width =   `REG_STATUS_FLAG_WIDTH +
 
                                                `REG_K_WIDTH +
 
                                                `L_C_WIDTH +
 
                                                `L_A_WIDTH +
 
                                                get_u_width() +
 
                                                `REG_ID_WIDTH +
 
                                                `L_E_REG_QM_WIDTH +
 
                                                15 +
 
                                                `REG_N_WIDTH + 
 
                                                $clog2(41+1) + 
 
                                                $clog2(211) +
 
                                                `REG_NU_WIDTH;
 
      return settings_loading_serialised_width;
 
  endfunction

There are some additions from the macros included within the package (eg: `REG_N_WIDTH )and some additions from the functions within the package (eg: get_u_width()). I then import this package within my top level module as localparam GET_SETTINGS: get_settings_loading_serialised_width( ) but i get the error: Verilog HDL Defparam Statement error at <location>:. Vivado does not have a problem with this.

P.S. I found that doing something like int a; a = `something; return a; works fine as compared to when int a = `something; return a;

Can anyone please help me with this?

Regards.

KhaiChein_Y_Intel · ‎02-25-2020

Hi,

May I know the software edition(Standard/Pro) and version you are using. Could you provide the .qar file for investigation?

Thanks.

Best regards,

KhaiY

AKhan88 · ‎02-25-2020

I am using Quartus Prime 18.1 (standard). I've found the problem. Apparently for Quartus, having a declaration and initialization on the same line (e.g int a = 10 -> Quartus treats this as a non-constant expression) is different from having a separate line for variable declaration and initalization (int a; a = 10; ->Quartus apparently likes this). This is very bizarre. I don't fully understand why this is the case.

KhaiChein_Y_Intel · ‎03-06-2020

Hi,

I cannot reproduce the error in your previous reply. Using int in the verilog file caused a syntax error. Could you provide the qar file for investigation?

Thanks.

Best regards,

KhaiY

AKhan88 · ‎03-06-2020

It's against my company policy to do so. Apologies for that.

If you really want to recreate it. Try doing what i did in the question i asked above. That function is inside a package and is imported within a module. Try compiling it in Quartus that way.

KhaiChein_Y_Intel · ‎03-09-2020

Hi,

I try to use int in the verilog HDL and the software issues a syntax error message. Could you provide a simple test case that can reproduce the error?

Thanks.

Best regards,

KhaiY

KhaiChein_Y_Intel · ‎03-20-2020

Hi,

Do you have any updates?

Thanks.

Best regards,

KhaiY