Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Honored Contributor I

OpenCL Channel and memory ordering

Are there any rules for ordering between channel writes and memory writes (and reads)? I am trying to write a pair of values, one to a channel and one to memory. The other kernel reads from the channel and must see the memory update. Are there any rules for this? I have looked up the manual and didn't find anything on this scenario.  

Would just using atomics to read/write the data in memory be sufficient? 

0 Kudos
1 Reply
Honored Contributor I

From what I understand, you are trying to use a channel to synchronize two kernels that share a global buffer, by sending tokens from one to the other whenever the data that is to be read, has been written. I personally tried doing this once, it didn't work (data got corrupted). When you write the data to the off-chip buffer and then write the token to the channel, since the latency of channel transfers is much lower than the off-chip memory transaction, the other kernel will likely get the token from the channel and read the memory location before it has actually been written to, and this will corrupt your data. I am not sure about atomic read/writes, though. The important point to note here is that the memory and the channel operation are all in the same pipeline; when the channel operation starts, it does NOT mean the memory operation that was before it has finished. 


You can also take a look at "Intel FPGA SDK for OpenCL - Programming Guide: Defining Memory Consistency Across Kernels When Using Channels". I tried to use the mem_fence(CLK_GLOBAL_MEM_FENCE) to mitigate the above issue but that didn't work either. Then again the description in that part of the document is not very clear and that mem_fence is probably not designed for the purpose I was trying to use it for.