FIFOed UART Qsys Generation Error with Qsys Standard v18.1

[TMK]

Hello,

when generating a FIFOed UART with Qsys Standard v18.1 as provided here

https://forums.intel.com/s/createarticlepage?language=en_US&articleid=a3g0P0000005RTHQA2&artTopicId=0TO0P000000MWKBWA4&action=view

I receive the following Qsys generation errors:

Info: tube_uart_0: Starting FIFOed UART Generation at C:/xy/Qsys/fifoed_uart

…

Info: tube_uart_0: Starting RTL generation for module 'f2flink_tube_uart_0'

…

Info: tube_uart_0:

Info: tube_uart_0: ERROR:

Info: tube_uart_0: no width for __0__/* synthesis keep */

Error: tube_uart_0: Failed to generate module f2flink_tube_uart_0

Info: tube_uart_0: Done RTL generation for module 'f2flink_tube_uart_0'

Info: tube_uart_0: "f2flink" instantiated fifoed_avalon_uart "tube_uart_0"

Error: Generation stopped, 15 or more modules remaining

This issue seems to be related to the Tx FIFO option (see screenshot).

Could you please let me know how this problem can be fixed and if a patch is available? Thank you.

Best regards,

Thomas

[KennyTan_Altera]

may I know what OS that you were using? I will try duplicate it and find the workaround for it.

[TMK]

I'm using Windows 7. Important information is that the problem only happens when generating VHDL (not Verilog) output and seems to be related to the synthesis directive.

[KennyTan_Altera]

I try it on VHDL and verilog, it get error. Where did you generate this IP? In the IP catalog or in the platform designer?

This IP was created in Q13.1, at that time, it is still using megafunction (not IP catalog) and this IP does not exist in the megafucntion.

You have use this IP in the platform designer. I try it on verilog and vhdl, I am using redhat. No error found when generating the IP.

Thanks

[TMK]

Well, as mentioned earlier I generate this IP in Platform Designer, formerly Qsys. Did you copy the settings from the screenshot to reproduce the problem? Please perform the following steps to reproduce the problem:

1. Create a Cyclone IV project
2. Open Platform Designer
3. Add a FIFOed UART instance
4. Enable the Tx FIFO
5. Set synthesis output to VHDL and generate the system

[KennyTan_Altera]

I am using Cyclone V, have ensure the same steps above. No eror.

The only different that we have is I am using redhat. Do you have other computer to try out? like windows 10?

[TMK]

Why don't you use Windows 10? Could you please share the Qsys generation report and a screenshot with the IP configuration settings?

[KennyTan_Altera]

I attached the screenshot, I do not have Q18.1 installed in my windows 10.

[TMK]

Thank you for the screenshots. My version is: Platform Designer 18.1 Build 625

Is it possible that you reproduce the problem in a Windows (7 or later) environment?

[KennyTan_Altera]

I will try it in Windows 10. but will need some time on this

[KennyTan_Altera]

Here is the result for windows 10.

[KennyTan_Altera]

Here is the zip files that I used.

[KennyTan_Altera]

any update?

[TMK]

Thank you for your update. In order to reproduce the issue you have to select "Create simulation model: VHDL" in the generation window. Could you please try that as well?

[KennyTan_Altera]

Well. I had try this before. no problem found as well.

[TMK]

As I'm able to reproduce the issue with the IP core provided by you and a new test system similar to yours, could you please try it again?

[TMK]

Btw, could you check with support why I permanently fail to log in to the Intel forum and it only works when I reset my password before?

[KennyTan_Altera]

You mention that you was able to reproduce the issue, are you using windows 7? As mention, I am using windows 10 and redhat. Would you able to use windows 10?

For reset password problem, can you file a new thread to address this differently?

[TMK]

My colleague has Windows 10 installed on his machine and is able to reproduce the problem as well. Could you please try again on Windows 10?

[KennyTan_Altera]

Today I tried again and I am getting error in windows 10, seems like I might have choose the wrong language in my previous test.

Error: fifoed_avalon_uart_0: Failed to generate module Test_fifoed_avalon_uart_131_rxorl4y

Info: fifoed_avalon_uart_0: Done RTL generation for module 'Test_fifoed_avalon_uart_131_rxorl4y'

Error: Generation stopped, 1 or more modules remaining

Info: Test: Done "Test" with 3 modules, 1 files

Error: qsys-generate failed with exit code 1: 2 Errors, 3 Warnings

If you swith from VHDL to verilog for simulation, the error goes away. Since modelsim able to support mixed language simulation, you will have to choose Verilog instead.

Please note that there will be no fixed/support for old version of IP (in your case Q13.1). We are sorry to inform that.

[TMK]

You mentioned that this is an old version of IP which implies that there is a newer one that is still under support. Could you please provide the version that is under support?